Supreme Court rules states may not criminalize blood test refusal, P.2

Previously, we began looking at a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling which held that states may not, under constitutional law, impose criminal penalties for a drunken driving suspect’s refusal to submit to a blood test. The case is significant not only because of the impact it will have upon the enforcement of drunken driving laws, but also because of the way it resolved previous case law.

The Supreme Court had previously ruled in Missouri v. McNeely (2013) that the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution requires officers to obtain a search warrant before taking a blood sample from a suspected drunken driven, unless a recognized exception applies. The specific issue in that case was whether the natural dissipation of alcohol categorically qualifies as an exception to the warrant requirement under the “exigent circumstances” exception. The answer to that question was, no. 

In light of the McNeely decision, there were questions about state implied consent laws which impose criminal penalties for refusing to submit to blood testing. McNeely had a blood sample forced upon him after he refused to submit to it under the state’s implied consent law. If, in light of McNeely, states could not force a warrantless blood draw without violating the Fourth Amendment, could they impose criminal penalties for refusing to submit to blood testing under implied consent laws? As we have seen, the answer was resolved in the negative, the court ruling in both cases for robust Fourth Amendment protections.  

In our next post, we’ll say a bit more about the impact the ruling may have in criminal cases.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Ready To Discuss Your Case?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Location:
140 S. Dearborn St Suite 411
Marquette Building
Chicago, IL 60603

Toll Free: 866-587-9887
Phone: 312-386-7033
Fax: 312-277-1920
Chicago Law Office Map

Phone Numbers: Review Us